Chapter 20 Section 4

Rights of the Accused: Punishment

 

Section Objective: To understand the constitutional limits on punishment for crime

 

A.     Excessive Bail, Fines

1          The 8th Amendment says that the bail or fine in a case must bear a reasonable relationship to the seriousness of the crime involved.

2           The use of bail is justified on two grounds.

a              A person should not be jailed until his or her guilt is established.

b              A defendant is better able to prepare for trial outside of jail.

3           Preventive Detention

a              A 184 law allows federal judges to hold an accused felon without bail if they believe it is necessary to protect the public from the accused.

b              Critics of this law say that it amounts to punishment before trial

B.     Cruel and Unusual Punishment

1          The 8th Amendment forbids cruel and unusual punishment.

2          The definition of �cruel and unusual� has been interpreted fairly narrowly by the Court.

C.    Capital Punishment 

1          In 1972 the Court struck down existing capital-punishment laws, saying that they left too much discretion to judges and juries.

2          It has since ruled that capital punishment can be applied only in cases resulting in the death of the victim, and in those cases mitigating circumstances must be considered.

D.    Treason

1          Treason is the only crime given a specific definition in the Constitution because the Framers knew that this charge is often used by tyrants to silence their opponents.

2           Treason is defined by the Constitutions as (1) levying war against the United States or (2) �adhering to their enemies, giving them aid and comfort.�

3           To convict a person of treason, the prosecution must produce two witnesses to the same overt act or a confession it open court.

4           Treason can be committed only in wartime.

5           Espionage, sabotage, and attempts to overthrow the government (either in peacetime or wartime) are also crimes.